Myths Inhibit Organ Donors, Kill People


Sometimes on WordPress, the formatting goes berserk.  It did in this post and I apologize for the variances in print style but it was beyond my control.


Some of the greatest barriers to organ donation are urban myths and there are hundreds of them.  Primary among them, though, is the tale that doctors will let you die so they can recover your organs.  This lie seems to have risen from a single unresolved case in a California hospital in 2006.  Before we get to that, though, here are two examples of how this myth manifests itself into supposedly true stories thereby preventing people from becoming organ donors.


  1. “My wife does not want me to be an organ donor because a few of her friends (who “just so happen to be ER nurses”) claim that when an organ donor is in a life & death situation on the table, doctors will not try and save them so that their organs may be used.  This sounds like it defeats the purpose; letting one die so another can live. But, she swears that it’s true.”
  2. “I heard that having the pink organ donor ticket on your driver license will cause the Paramedics to allow you to die in order to harvest your organs. The rumor claims that due to the long list of people on the organ waiting list, the Paramedics are instructed to allow organ donors to die.”


First and foremost it is important to note that the medical team treating you in a hospital or ER is completely separate from the transplant team. The organ procurement organization (OPO) is not notified until all lifesaving efforts have failed and brain death has been determined by certified neurologists. The OPO does not even notify the transplant team of organ availability until the donor’s family has consented to donation., a wonderful source for dispelling myths, rumors and outright lies offers a concise and accurate explanation ( I encourage you to click on the link and read the entire entry but here are some of the more salient points. 

While the rumor would appear to confirm the belief that physicians involved in harvesting organs will happily sacrifice one patient in their efforts to secure parts for others, such belief overlooks one particular facet of this conjecture: Doctors who fail to provide their best medical care to their patients can and will be sued. As professional healers, they are held to a higher legal “standard of care” than is the average person and thus aren’t afforded the luxury in life or death situations of not attempting to do all in their power to save those whose lives hang in the balance. Additionally, in those instances where patients died, doctors who did decide to scale back care could well be charged with homicide.”

So you might ask, “How did this rumor get started?”  Again, according to Snopes:

“The rumor about organ-hungry doctors prematurely offing potential donors gained an unfortunate shot in the arm from a 2006 case in San Luis Obispo, California. Ruben Navarro, a 25-year-old man who suffered from the neurological disorder adrenoleukodystrophy as a child (by his early 20s his mental and physical condition had deteriorated to a point where he was placed in an assisted-care facility), was admitted lifeless and unresponsive to the Sierra Vista Regional Medical Center on 29 January 2006. His organs were subsequently retrieved for transplant five days later. (Those transplants, by the way, never took place because Navarro survived for more than seven hours after he was removed from life support and was given certain drugs, so his organs had deteriorated too much to be usable.)

Prosecutors have charged Dr. Hootan C. Roozrokh, the surgeon who removed Navarro’s organs, with felony counts of dependent adult abuse, mingling a harmful substance (Betadine) and prescribing a controlled substance (morphine and Ativan) without medical purpose. It is their assertion that rather than allow Navarro to die naturally, the doctor knowingly hastened the process by introducing into him excessive amounts of narcotic painkillers and sedatives for the express purpose of killing him. The doctor is also said to have administered the antiseptic Betadine through a feeding tube into Navarro’s stomach while Navarro was still viable, a sterilization procedure typically done after a donor is dead (since it’s likely to kill the living).

Roozrokh’s attorney says Navarro “was going to die shortly, whether in minutes or in hours” and said of the excessive painkillers used that “In that situation, you err on the side of ensuring that he’s pain-free.” Over-medicating the dying with morphine is not at all a new practice; terminal patients are sometimes given unusually high or overly-frequent doses of the drug in an effort (generally unstated but also generally understood by both medical staff and family members in attendance) to help the dying slip through death’s door a bit more quickly and thus terminate sufferers’ torments sooner. Such practice is generally roundly denied when spoken of openly, however.

Dr. Roozrokh continues to practice, pending the verdict in his case.”

If you would like comprehensive information on other organ donation/transplantation myths please visit

Please comment in the space provided or email your thoughts to me at  And – please spread the word about the need for more organ donors.  There is nothing you can do that is of greater importance.  If you convince one person to be a donor you may have saved or affected  over 50 lives.


Please read and comment on my World Wide Issues blogs on   Also…visit and join my Facebook site, Organ Transplant Patients, Friends and You at  OR — my Facebook home page 

About these ads

About Bob Aronson

About Bob Aronson On August 21, 2007 I received a new heart at the Mayo Clinic in Jacksonville, Florida. All these years later I am very active, happy and loving life. God bless my donor and his family. His generosity toward a complete stranger will never be forgotten. I am retired and live with my wife Robin and two dogs Reilly the main dog and Ziggy the backup. We are a very happy family. My gratitude to my wonderful caregiver wife, my donor, his family and the Mayo Clinic is beyond my ability to express. Suffice it to say I will do whatever is in my power to promote organ and tissue donation and to help and support everyone affected by the issue. As a result of receiving the “Gift of Life” I have made a major commitment to organ/tissue/blood donation, transplantation and related issues. I am the founder of Facebook's over 4,000 member support group, Organ Transplant Initiative (OTI) and the blog site, “Bob’s Newheart” I have authored the great majority of the nearly 250 blogs listed there. The remainder were written by excellent guest bloggers. The posts span a wide variety of topics mostly involving organ/tissue donation/transplantation and related issues, but also covering important current medical news and information. Wordpress data indicate the blogs have readers in 162 countries. Bob's Newheart is quickly becoming the news and information source of choice for those with an interest in organ/tissue donation/transplantation along with current developments in medical news and health care. Born In Chisholm, Minnesota I now reside in Jacksonville, Florida. I have three children and one step son, 8 grandchildren and 3 great grandchildren. My three grown children are Roger Aronson a well-known and respected Minneapolis, Minnesota Attorney, Dr. Colleen Hegranes Senior Vice President St. Catherine University in St. Paul, Minnesota and Harryet (Hank) Freeman who is probably the best history teacher in America, at least that's what her students at Woodbury, Minnesota High school tell me. Stepson Tim Grant and wife Jennifer live a couple of blocks from us in Jacksonville. Jen is a talented cook, baker, and mother. Tim is an in-demand electrician in Jacksonville who can really make almost anything work. Stella and Lily Grant are two very bright and talented granddaughters. For 25 plus years I owned the Aronson Communications Group an international consultancy specializing in health care communication. The Mayo Clinic was my first consulting client, a relationship that lasted until my retirement. I also worked with 3M health care, UNOS, LIfeSource, Dartmouth University Medical Center and CH2M HILL, one of the nation's largest environmental engineering firms. Prior to being a consultant I served for four years as the first Anchor for Morning Edition on the Minnesota Public Radio Network; was the Communications director for Minnesota Governor Rudy Perpich and before that held positions as a broadcast journalist at several Midwest facilities. I also served as the Director of broadcast communications at Moorhead State University in Moorhead, Minnesota. While I am retired Robin is not and I assist her efforts as founder and owner of Jingler’s Jewelry. She designs and makes colorful, "Fun" anodized aluminum jewelry and is also an accomplished printmaker. She sells her creations at art shows, festivals and gift shops in states east of the Mississippi but mostly in the south. Her website is When I have time, my hobbies include reading, music and woodworking. One of my most notable projects was completing a wood scale model of the mom and pop grocery store my parents ran for 50 years in Chisholm, Minnesota. The model now resides in Chisholm in my sister's home. Our parents were wonderful people who instilled in us a very strong work ethic and a sense of fairness and equality. I also built a dollhouse for granddaughter Lily Grant and just completed designing and building a CD box that looks like an accordion. A friend commissioned me to make it in memory of his father who was an accomplished accordion musician. I have a brother and sister of whom I am very proud . They are twins. Terry is a Minnesota District Court Judge and Mary a retired but still the best 3rd grade teacher in America. I am proud of them for what they have done but more importantly for who they are. My wife Robin is a caregiver, musician, artist, entrepreneur and the best friend I have. While we do a lot of things together we especially like making music. Often in the evening you can hear the strains of folk, Blue Grass, country and other music coming from our family room. Robin plays several instruments including string bass, accordion, guitar, ukulele, mandolin and...well the list goes on. I play harmonica and have one in almost every key. She's really good...I'm not. Quantity does not ensure quality. One more thing. I am also a recovering Alcoholic and a former smoker. I emerged from a 28 day in-patient alcoholism treatment program in August of 1982 and have managed to stay sober with the help of a lot of people both in and out of Alcoholics Anonymous. I quit smoking in January of 1991 after a 37 year habit of up to four packs of cigarettes a day. It wasn’t easy but I’m living proof that it can be done. I am available to anyone suffering from or affected by any addiction at any time through my email address or via phone 904-434-6512.

Posted on March 13, 2009, in Organ Donation. Bookmark the permalink. 4 Comments.

  1. I find it truly disturbing that so many seemingly intelligent people buy into these bullshit myths. The #1 thing that needs to be understood is that thousands of people die each and every day and yet MOST OF THOSE BODIES CAN’T BE USED FOR TRANSPLANTS!

    ► Most overweight people’s organs can’t be used…
    ► People with many preexisting conditions organs can’t be used…
    ► People that die of most natural causes have infections so their organs can’t be used…

    If everyone that went into the hospital was murdered for their organs, why would people still be dying due to lack of transplant material?

    The United States needs to do what they do in most Western European Countries and make it so that you are AUTOMATICALLY an organ donor and rather than having to sign-up, you must go in to opt-out and that increases the chances that when someone passes away with USEABLE organs, they don’t go to waste.

    Too many people have this idea that when their organs get used, it will mean something about their afterlife… They think about organ donation in terms of them still being alive… They see themselves as “Special” and “Individuals” and the very idea of death already terrifies them so the idea that they’ll have parts of them removed and used, even to save the lives of others, as if these organs would be removed while they are still there to witness things…


    When your dead, you’re absolutely no different than the steak your going to eat for dinner tonight.

    You won’t be watching yourself from “Heaven”.
    You won’t be a ghost watching as pieces of you are given to others.
    You won’t magically be transported into the body of the person your organs go to.


    You’ll be dead and you’ll be gone… All that will be left is the hunks of fat and tissue that can save lives.

    I’m disgusted that so many people in our culture can’t differentiate between their conscious lives and death.


  2. Geez…someone told this myth today. I should’ve corrected him that people go to frikking jail/get sued if they kill someone just to take their organs.


  3. Vell, nоt pеrfеct рost, but I liked it аnd that is thе main thing. ;)
    I am Voli Dublino


  4. very nice share much appriciated


Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 2,377 other followers

%d bloggers like this: